Open in app
Home
Notifications
Lists
Stories

Write
Ian Wardell
Ian Wardell

Home

About

13 hours ago

It's rather amusing that you happily accept the perhaps thousands of accounts somewhat consistent…
1

Rex Kerr

The Mind-Brain Correlations

The Mind-Brain Correlations I agree that the mind being adversely affected by an impaired brain is indeed consistent with a “physical basis for consciousness”. The problem here is that it’s also consistent with brains not creating consciousness. To my mind, your argument here for the physical basis of the mind…

5 min read


Jul 17

Neither we nor the Earth are special?

Annaka Harris, the wife of Sam Harris, says in an article Each transformative shift in our understanding of the universe has delivered the ego-shattering message that we’re not special-Earth is not the center of the universe, and life, including the human brain, is made up of the same particles as…

Earth

3 min read

Neither we nor the Earth are special?
Neither we nor the Earth are special?

May 31

Damaged brains can result in damaged minds, does this mean there is no soul?

All aspects of consciousness — whether pains, perceptual experiences, thoughts and so on — can be changed, attenuated, modulated, even stopped altogether by the brain. Those who are skeptical of the existence of a soul make great play of this and appear to think this presents almost incontrovertible evidence that…

Afterlife

2 min read


May 10

Science, the Afterlife, and the Intelligentsia

1. Introduction I read this article by a professor of philosophy called John G Messerly. He says: There has been a dramatic change in the last few centuries in the proportion of believers among the highly educated in the Western world. In the European Middle Ages belief in a God was ubiquitous…

Afterlife

17 min read

Science, the Afterlife, and the Intelligentsia
Science, the Afterlife, and the Intelligentsia

May 6

Thanks again Ian for clarifying your position further.
1

Dan Sumner

No, I've never had an NDE.

No, I've never had an NDE. Nor had a mystical experience. Nor had a psychedelic trip (these can resemble NDEs, such as DMT trips). I guess you haven't either? I think we might both be in a better position if we had an NDE to better assess whether it's a…

2 min read


May 6

Thanks ever so much for responding Ian and taking the time to present some interesting criticisms…
1

Dan Sumner

I don't understand what is meant by saying an NDE is a "preparation" for an afterlife.

I don't understand what is meant by saying an NDE is a "preparation" for an afterlife. The NDE is where the soul becomes detached from the body, full stop (or period as the Americans say). It's not a preparation, we need to do that before we die! …

3 min read


May 5

Neuroscience Explains: Near-death experiences
1
1

Dan Sumner

I don't understand why having NDEs where one isn't anywhere near death somehow provides a reason to…

I don't understand why having NDEs where one isn't anywhere near death somehow provides a reason to suppose NDEs aren't a glimpse of an afterlife? Why does one necessarily have to be near death in order to have a glimpse of the afterlife realm? And even if we accept that…

1 min read


May 2

Are Perceptual illusions always necessarily illusions?

I’m sure that all of us are astounded that the squares A and B are actually the same colour. It is the shadow cast over B by the cylinder that makes us think otherwise. What this suggests is a quite incredible illusion. However, I think there is a pervasive naivety…

Illusion

3 min read

Are Perceptual illusions always necessarily illusions?
Are Perceptual illusions always necessarily illusions?

Apr 20

How do our brains make our minds?
170
7

Oxford Academic

I don’t believe there’s actually any evidence whatsoever.

"[M]any distinguished thinkers [have] despair[ed] of ever being able to explain how a mind emerges from a brain, despite overwhelming experimental evidence that it does". I don’t believe there’s actually any evidence whatsoever. I presume you’re referring to the fact that damaged brains lead to damaged minds. Well.. . …

2 min read


Apr 18

There’s 2 possibilities:

There are 2 possibilities: 1) This is the only life there is. When we die we simply cease to exist. Our lives and the Universe are, in a sense, ultimately absurd. In that case nothing we do ultimately matters. How much money we accumulate and our social status are transitory…

Afterlife

1 min read

There’s 2 possibilities:
There’s 2 possibilities:
Ian Wardell

Ian Wardell

Following
  • Nick Nielsen

    Nick Nielsen

  • Julia Mossbridge, PhD

    Julia Mossbridge, PhD

  • Tony Walker

    Tony Walker

  • Dan Sumner

    Dan Sumner

  • Medium

    Medium

Help

Status

Writers

Blog

Careers

Privacy

Terms

About

Knowable